h) Culture, history and literature
A one-sided portrayal of Tasmania
This article on "Whatever Happened to Brenda Hean?" was published in the Hobart Mercury on 8.10.08.
When Brant Webb and Todd Russell emerged from the gold mine that almost became their grave, they were hailed “great Australian heroes”.
But when they stumbled in an interview with Oprah, the mainland media immediately dubbed them “inarticulate Tasmanian miners”.
It’s not an isolated example.
Ricky Ponting is “a great captain” when the Australian cricket team wins, but on more than one occasion has been dismissed by mainland commentators as “a former Tasmanian player” when it lost.
Bob Brown is hailed nationally as “a global environmental hero” when he stands against climate change, but in the mainland press Guy Barnett is consistently “a Senator from Tasmania” when he opposes social change.
It seems when Tasmanians do something brave or good it’s despite us being Tasmanian. When we fall, fail, or do something others don’t like, it’s because we’re Tasmanian.
The latest example is the much-anticipated documentary, “Whatever happened to Brenda Hean?”, about the unexplained and suspicious disappearance of conservationist, Brenda Hean, and her pilot, Max Price, on a flight to Canberra to raise awareness about Lake Pedder’s flooding in 1972.
It’s an important story that documentary-maker, Scott Millwood, tells fairly well, except in one crucial respect.
The documentary portrays Tassie as a place of exceptional corruption, of unusual violence against those who are different, and of unmatched silence about both.
This corruption, violence and silence is explained in terms of our past as a brutal prison where native people and animals were treated exceptionally badly.
I have no argument with this. My experience as a gay rights campaigner tells me things can be even worse than Millwood’s film says.
But it also tells me that his grim, “gothic” view of Tasmania is only part of the truth.
There is another Tasmania, a Tasmania of belonging, joy, freedom, beauty, abundance and love, which is greater than our island’s closed and hateful “twin”.
This “good Tasmania” is the one I grew up with on a dairy farm near Sheffield.
It is the Tasmania which can boast globally-significant achievements on the environment, democracy and social justice.
It is the Tasmania that has inspired our painters and writers for generations.
It is the Tasmania that historian James Boyce has traced back to the earliest days of European settlement when “brutal” convicts rapidly developed a stronger sense of community, a closer connection to the land and a greater sense of freedom than people anywhere else in the English-speaking world.
But Millwood is blind to this Tasmania, despite having spent most of his life here.
The environmental campaigners he interviews are not put in a Tasmanian context in the same way as their opponents, they have no obvious history here and their achievements after Pedder are not mentioned.
If you knew nothing else about this island and its environmental movement than what is in Millwood’s film, you would be left with the impression that a few green heroes suddenly sprang from nowhere to unsuccessfully battle a monster called “Tasmania”.
But the truth is that Tasmania’s conservation movement has been immensely successful, and that this success is largely because it is a Tasmanian movement that draws inspiration from what’s best about the place.
If Brenda Hean were alive today she would thank Scott Millwood for keeping her work and her cause alive.
But I suspect she might add that whatever bravery, dauntlessness and hope she showed, arose from an optimism about Tasmania which his film does not share.
My hope is that Millwood’s next film is about what Tasmanians can achieve, not just what we destroy.
Rodney Croome is a former editor of Island magazine.
[ Email This Article ]
Whatever happened to Brenda Hean?”, about the unexplained and suspicious disappearance of conservationist, Brenda Hean, and her pilot.
Yeah what happeneds to Breanda Hean?
The truth is that Tasmania’s conservation movement has been immensely successful, and that this success is largely because it is a Tasmanian movement that draws inspiration from what’s best about the place.
Is Miss Breanda Hean alive ?
I read it and i enjoy, if i can give you an advice, buy it, and read it !!
"The documentary portrays Tassie as a place of exceptional corruption, of unusual violence against those who are different, and of unmatched silence about both.
This corruption, violence and silence is explained in terms of our past as a brutal prison where native people and animals were treated exceptionally badly."
I don't like it when they purposefully bias their accounts without showing some of the better aspects of the country.
I read it and i enjoy it very much
Very good post,I read it, it's very interesting
like you very much
funny my friend
you are so good ,haha
let me bookmark you
A good documentary that uncovers Tasmania's secrets. Marco
Nice topic, very usefull !
thx a lot :)
very nice post!!! thanks
intereting post.. thanks!!!
Buy cheap eyeglasses in this economic crisis moment. -BWW
Pass4sure is an expert in providing the most valuable training materials for IT certification exams. Comprehensive and latest practice exams, 100% pass guarantee policy, professional pre-sale and post-sale service, all these protect your way on preparation for IT certification exams. Numerous vendors provide customers with a wide rang of choices.<br>The Most Popular Certifications List :<br><br><br>Click Passforsure to get more information!-BWW
cheers for the post.
cheers for the post
Very nice post abotu culture of Tasmania, I need to do homework for this topic!!
thanks so much
<br> christian audigier <a title="christian audigier" href="http://www.edhardysell.com/christian-audigier.html" rel="dofollow">christian audigier</a>
<br> ed hardy mens <a title="ed hardy mens" href="http://www.edhardysell.com/mens.html" rel="dofollow">ed hardy mens</a>
<br> ed hardy womens <a title="ed hardy womens" href="http://www.edhardysell.com/womens.html" rel="dofollow">ed hardy womens</a>
<br> ed hardy kids <a title="ed hardy kids" href="http://www.edhardysell.com/kids.html" rel="dofollow">ed hardy kids</a>
where can i buy cheap handbags wholesale.it will be better if can accept paypal.its really a nice link deal with discount coach handbags,free shipping and no risk.70% family of US would like imitation from Asia,such as replica coach products,there are really with high quanlity and wholesale price.
In the warriorepic, warriorepic Goldis very important. You can do some task, and with your friends together to buy warriorepic Gold. Only to spend some time and money, you will get more warriorepic money
lili lili lili
welcome to buy wedding dresses
Free shipping, fashion style. cheaper price
The variety of coach handbags are so many that the discount coach handbag almost becomes difficult to choose the right one. Well the coach handbag outlet is one that is certainly unique and different.