a) Gay Tasmania
Catholic student quota push opposed
This article was published on the Tasmanian Times website on June 1st, 2007.
44% of the almost-15,000 students at Tasmaniaís Catholic schools are not Catholic, the highest proportion in the nation.
The parents of these students obviously believe that thereís something valuable about Catholic education which is more important than faith.
Whether that something is discipline, ethics, or "tradition and spirit" as the St Virgilís ads say, itís clearly important to thousands of non-Catholic parents to have a choice about where they send their kids.
Now the Catholic Church wants the State Government to help it limit that choice.
Archbishop Adrian Doyle has said that 75% of students at Catholic schools must be Catholic or from Catholic families, beginning with the new Catholic College in Kingston, and he is lobbying to have the Anti-Discrimination Act changed so that his schools can discriminate on the grounds of religion when it comes to who they enrol.
In Doyleís words,
"The first obligation of Catholic education is to Catholic students and their families. (But) from a technical point of view, this places the Catholic education system Ö in breach of the Anti-Discrimination Act."
The new direction of Catholic education raises many questions.
For example, who defines "Catholic"?
Will students be turned away because their parents are single, in de facto relationships or not regular church goers?
Will students be expelled if they are found with contraception, come out as gay or question Catholic doctrine?
Some Catholics will ask whether the new policy will actually benefit committed Christians, or just encourage more people to pretend to religious convictions they donít really hold?
Tax-payers will ask whether the first obligation of the Catholic education system isnít to the broader Australian community which provides the vast bulk of its funding.
Catholic educators themselves have questioned the wisdom of setting targets for Catholic student enrolment with the Director of Victoriaís Catholic Education Office, Susan Pascoe, predicting enrolments will drop by 10%, sending smaller Catholic schools to the wall.
The problem will be even greater in Tasmania where the Churchís 75% target requires it to find Catholics to fill a massive 20-25% of current and future places.
There are also important questions for the Lennon Government to answer about the new Catholic school policy.
Will it weaken an Act which has been hailed as setting world-class benchmarks of fairness and equity and which was one of the greatest achievements of the Bacon Government?
If it gives in to the Church now how many other demands for religious exemptions will it concede to?
The Anti-Discrimination Act already has provisions allowing the Commissioner to grant exemptions if she is convinced they are necessary.
Why canít the Church go through this process like everyone else, rather than waste Parliamentís time with special legislation?
But beyond all these legitimate questions, the basic issue remains parental choice and what happened to it?
For years the Catholic education system has defended its existence, and its substantial public funding, on the basis that it provides all parents with a choice about how their children are schooled.
If that choice is reduced, thereís a strong argument the funding itís based on should be reduced as well.
Non-Catholic families who have been loyal supporters and full-fee payers to their local Catholic school deserve better than to be sent to the end of the enrolment queue.
Tax-payers deserve better than to be asked to fund a new kind of sectarianism that favours one religion over another.
Tasmanians deserve better than to have their strong anti-discrimination protections worn away by political expediency.
We all deserve better than to live in a society where a young personís religious faith or background is the key to their educational opportunities.
Rodney Croome is a spokesperson for the Tasmanian Gay and Lesbian Rights Group.
1. Percentage of non-Catholics in Tasmanian Catholic schools
Cardinal George Pell, "Religion and Culture: Catholic Schools in Australia: Keynote address to the 2006 National Catholic Education Conference", Sydney,
September 28th 2006
2. Number of students in Tasmanian Catholic schools
Tasmanian Catholic Education Office, "2006 Full Time Enrolments by Year Level and Gender"
3. Targets for Tasmanian Catholic school enrolment and amendments to the Anti-Discrimination Act
Archbishop Adrian Doyle, quoted on ABC TV News, 28.5.07 and in the Mercury, 31.5.07
4. Catholic educators question enrolment caps for non-Catholic students
Vic CEO Director, Susan Pascoe, quoted in "Catholic school policy warning" by Chee Chee Leung, Education Reporter, The Age, April 8th, 2005
[ Email This Article ]
Feel difficult to find your favorite Tiffany jewelry like earrings? United Kingdom online store Tiffanysjewellery.co.uk is your best destination. links london are well known for their highest quality and characteristic designs. Tiffanys Jewellery Offer a wide range of fashionable Tiffany Jewellery, including links of london jewellery, tiffany necklaces, tiffany pendants, tiffany bracelets, tiffany earrings and tiffany accessories.We have added 200+ Packaging for our customers at hot price. We offer some of the latest styles in Tiffany genuine Silver Jewelry today.
<p>Now i am very happy, Thank you for my beautiful Ugg Classic Cardy Boots, I can't get mine back from my mum so I'll be ordering another pair from that cheap ugg boots store tomorrow. Ugg boots on sale!</p>
<p> They really don't have a shape to them, make women look like they have big feet, and they also look like you're walking around in public with slippers .. That's ugg boots! Lol!!! Uggs boots on sale, i will buy one pair!</p>
Anybody can tell me where i can buy the best and the cheapest shoes ，I have to tell him that is christian louboutin shoes ,it will be your right choice.
Great!wow gold Campus of the University who has clearly inherited the brain remnants of these shares of lonely trend! c
Supposed to attack these head-on and you will find a deep sense of gratification thatwill fuel your happiness. Maybe you are also interested in Christian Louboutin shoes. I'm just hearing the curiosity behind it.
I have to say that this site is awesome and has kept me entertained on my time off from work. keep it up.Once upon a time, two women created the cutest velour hoodies and matching drawstring pants. The line was called Christian Louboutin and every starlet in Tinseltown had to have one. Soon after, so did the rest of the world. Now the once little brand has blossomed into a fashion empire, complete with clothing, Christian Louboutin Shoes, jewelry, handbags, and most recently, fragrance.
Return to weblog.
rain common people, and bring benefit of! Deep through your words, I seem to see the eagle as the wolf you care, Dragon Tiger stalwart heroic step;